Hindu man who had escaped the Kashmiri Hindu genocide, killed by his Muslim neighbour

Case ID : 90a0595 | Location : Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh, India | Date of Incident : Tue, 14 January, 2025
Case ID : 90a0595
location Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh, India
date 14 January, 2025
Hindu man who had escaped the Kashmiri Hindu genocide, killed by his Muslim neighbour
Attack resulting in death
Attacked for opposing radicals or trying to save victim
Attacked for Hindu identity

Case Summary

On 15th January 2025, in Bareilly, an elderly Hindu man named Harbans Lal was killed after an assault by his Muslim neighbours. According to media reports he had a conflict with his Muslim neighbour over the cooking of meat and wanted to put fibre sheets on the wall to keep the smell of meat out. Sagir Ahmed, the Muslim neighbour of Harbans had objected to the wall being covered up with fibre sheets and had fought with Harbans. According to the complaint filed by Harbans Lal’s son Hemant, Sagir and his wife fought with Harbans and their fight escalated and Sagir and his wife allegedly pushed Harbans Lal and hit him. Harbans Lal fell and was injured. He was rushed to the hospital where he was declared dead. According to Hemant Lal, his family was a victim of the Kashmiri Pandit exodus and they had eventually settled in Bareilly after escaping from Kashmir decades ago. In the colony, there were around 32 Hindu families and Sagir’s family was the only Muslim family in the neighbourhood. He added that they never had any fight with other neighbours except Sagir’s family. In-charge Inspector of Baradari police station Dhananjay Pandey registered a case of unintentional murder against Sagir and his wife.

Why it is Hate Crime ?

This case has been added to the tracker under the prime category of- Attack resulting in death and under this the first sub-category selected is- Attacked for Hindu identity. In several cases, Hindus are attacked merely for their Hindu identity without any perceived provocation. A classic example of this category of religiously motivated hate crime is a murder in 2016. 7 ISIS terrorists were convicted for shooting a school principal in Kanpur because they got ‘triggered’ seeing the Kalava on his wrist and tilak that he had put. In this, the Hindu victim had offered no provocation except for his Hindu religious identity. The motivation for the murder was purely religious, driven by religious supremacy. Such cases where Hindus are targeted merely for their religious identity would be documented as a hate crime. Under this category, cases where the attack led to the death of the Hindu victim/s would be documented. The second sub-category selected here is- Attacked for opposing radicals or trying to save victim. In several cases, Hindus are attacked for opposing religiously motivated crimes being committed against a fellow Hindu or simply for voicing an opinion opposing radical elements, who either have in the past or continue to persecute Hindus. In such cases, the initial attack against the victim, against which the Hindu was trying to defend the victim, would also need to be classified as a religiously motivated hate crime. Since the initial crime itself was religiously motivated and the subsequent crime of attempting to save the victim or speaking against the radical elements ends up inviting a violent attack, it would also be classified as a religiously motivated hate crime. Under this category, cases where the attack led to the death of the Hindu victim/s would be documented. The religious marker in this case is the conflict over the cooking of meat, which directly ties into Hindu religious sensitivities. Harbans Lal, a Hindu man, sought to install fibre sheets to shield his home from the smell of meat, a step he took in accordance with his religious and personal beliefs. However, his Muslim neighbour, Sagir Ahmed, not only objected to this but also engaged in a violent altercation that ultimately led to Harbans Lal’s death. The act of forcefully preventing a Hindu man from mitigating the impact of something that is religiously offensive to him—and resorting to physical violence over it—demonstrates an attack on his religious identity. Furthermore, the broader context of Harbans Lal’s background as a Kashmiri Hindu refugee, who had already faced religious persecution in the past, adds to the pattern of targeting based on faith. The fact that the conflict did not arise from a general neighbourhood dispute but was instead rooted in a religiously sensitive issue—his attempt to shield himself from the smell of meat—marks this as a hate crime with clear religious motivation. The attack was not merely about a difference in lifestyle; it was an assertion of dominance by denying Harbans Lal his right to practice his religious preferences in his own home, escalating into fatal violence.

Victim Details

Total Victim

1

Deceased

1


Gender

  • Male 1
  • Female 0
  • Third Gender 0
  • Unknown 0

Caste

  • SC/ST 0
  • OBC 0
  • General 1
  • Unknown 0

Age Group

  • Minor 0
  • Adult 0
  • Senior Citizen 1
  • Unknown 0
Case Status Background
Gavel Icon

Case Status


Complaint filed

Case Status Background
Gavel Icon

Perpetrators Details

Perpetrators


Muslim Extremists

Perpetrators Range


From 2 To 5

Perpetrators Gender


both

Case Details SVG
The details of each case are updated till the day it has been added to the database. It is not practical for us to manually track the progress of every case listed in the Hinduphobia Tracker database. If you have additional information which you believe should reflect here, please provide additional details by clicking the button below. If you believe this case should not be considered a religiously motivated hate crime, you can proceed to raise a dispute using the same button.
Please note the case ID: 90a0595 <click to copy case id>, you must enter the same in the form which will pop up after clicking the button.