Hindu faith targeted: Kashmiri Muslim man openly opposes temples, objects to Hindu religious practices, threatens to burn temple in his village
Case Summary
In Lolabh, Dharpura, Kashmir, a 30-year-old Kashmiri Muslim man named Mushtaq Aman openly expressed hostility towards the Hindu faith, Hindu temples and religious worship during a video interview with a female interviewer. He objected to the opening of Hindu temples, described Hindu puja-path (worship) as bad and unacceptable, and expressed strong resentment towards hearing bhajans (Hindu devotional songs) while going to offer namaz (Muslim prayers). He also objected to loudspeakers used for Hindu religious worship and stated that he had a serious problem with Hindu religious practices. Most disturbingly, when asked what would happen if a Hindu temple were constructed in his village, he explicitly threatened to burn it down. During the interview, the female interviewer asked Mushtaq Aman whether the construction of a temple or the presence of alcohol bothered him more. He identified alcohol as his primary concern, followed by the construction of a temple. When the interviewer questioned his objection to opening a temple, he said that although everyone follows their own religion, opening a temple was unacceptable. Mushtaq Aman further stated that whenever he stepped out of his home in the morning as a Muslim, particularly when heading towards a mosque, he had a serious objection to puja-path (Hindu religious worship). When asked how he would react to hearing bhajans (Hindu devotional songs) emanating from a temple while on his way to offer namaz, he expressed strong discomfort, saying such religious expressions were unacceptable to him. Mushtaq Aman stated that there was no temple in his village, although temples existed in Kupwara and Srinagar. When asked about the prospect of a temple being constructed in his village, Mushtaq Aman issued a direct threat, stating that they would set it on fire. He later qualified his position, saying temple construction was acceptable on privately owned land but objected to any such construction on their land or near a mosque.
Why it is Hate Crime ?
This case has been added to the tracker under the primary category- Hate Speech against Hindus. The subcategory selected is- Anti-Hindu slurs, mocking faith. Anti-Hindu slurs and the deliberate mocking of the Hindu faith owing to religious animosity involve the use of derogatory terms, stereotypes, or offensive references to religious practices, symbols, or figures. One of the common anti-Hindu slurs used against Hindus is “cow-worshipper” and “cow piss drinker”. The intention of using these terms is to demean and mock Hindus as a group and their religious beliefs since Hindus consider the cow holy. Additionally, some symbols and the slurs attached to them have a historical context that exacerbates the insult, hate, stereotyping, dehumanisation and oppression against Hindus. Cow worship has been used for centuries to denigrate Hindus, insult their faith and oppress Hindus specifically as a religious group. There has been overwhelming documentation about how cow slaughter has been used to persecute Hindus with cow meat being thrown in temples and places of worship. There has also been overwhelming documentation where cow meat (beef) has been force-fed to Hindus to either forcefully convert them to Islam or denigrate their faith. Apart from cow worship, the Swastika – which holds deep religious significance for the Hindus – has also been misinterpreted and distorted to use as a slur against Hindus. Similarly, the worship of the Shivling has been used by supremacist ideologies and religions to denigrate Hindus owing to religious animosity. Such slurs and denigration stem out of inherent animosity and hate towards Hindus and their faith, therefore, it is categorised as hate speech targeted at Hindus specifically owing to their religious identity. The other subcategory selected is: Violent threats. Violent threats, explicit, implicit or implied, is the most dangerous form of hate speech since it goes beyond discriminatory and prejudicial language to express the intent of causing harm to an individual or a group of people based on their religious identity and faith. There could be several different kinds of threats that are issued to Hindus based on religious animosity. An explicit threat would mean the direct threat of violence towards an individual Hindu, a group of Hindus or Hindus at large. Physical violence, death threats, threats of destruction of property belonging to Hindus and threats of genocide would mean explicit threats against Hindus for their religious identity. Implicit threats may not be a direct threat but implied through the use of symbols of actions – for example – in the Nupur Sharma case, other than explicit threats, there were also implicit threats when Islamists took to the streets to burn and beat her effigies. It implies that they want to do the same to Nupur Sharma – thereby is considered an implicit threat. Violent threats can be delivered in person, through letters, phone calls, graffiti, or increasingly through social media and other online platforms. It would be important to understand that a threat – explicit or implicit, online or offline – to an individual who happens to be a Hindu does not qualify as a religiously motivated threat. Such a threat, while vile and dangerous, could be owing to non-religious reasons and/or personal animosity. To qualify as a religiously motivated threat, it would need to exhibit an indication that the individual is being targeted for religious reasons and/or owing to his/her religious identity as a Hindu. This case represents a clear example of religiously driven hate, as the Muslim perpetrator expressed strong objections to Hindu temples, puja-path and bhajans, and explicitly threatened to burn down a temple if one were constructed in his village. His remarks directly targeted Hindu religious practices and the establishment of places of worship. By expressing intolerance towards Hindu worship and threatening the destruction of a temple, his statements constituted a direct challenge to religious freedom and communal harmony, making this a distinct instance of targeted anti-Hindu hostility. The Muslim perpetrator's opposition to the opening and construction of Hindu temples reflected direct hostility towards Hindu religious identity and the right of Hindus to practise their faith. Temples hold immense religious and cultural importance for Hindus, serving as sacred places where devotees worship their deities, offer prayers, perform rituals and observe religious ceremonies. By objecting to the establishment of Hindu temples in his village, he displayed clear intolerance towards the presence of Hindu places of worship. His remarks went far beyond an ordinary disagreement over construction or land ownership, as he specifically opposed establishing a place dedicated to Hindu worship. His hostility became even more serious when he explicitly threatened to burn down a temple if one were constructed in his village. This was a direct threat against a sacred Hindu institution and exposed an alarming willingness to use violence and destruction against a place of Hindu worship. Such a threat struck at the basic religious rights of Hindus, who are entitled to establish temples and worship without facing intimidation. His statements reflected an exclusionary attitude towards Hindu religious institutions, as though the presence of a temple in his village was something that could not be tolerated. Threatening to destroy a Hindu temple simply because it represented another faith demonstrated open hostility towards Hinduism and its religious presence. Equally concerning was his objection to puja-path (Hindu worship), bhajans and other Hindu religious practices, which reflected deep intolerance towards the everyday religious expressions of Hindus. Puja-path is an essential part of Hindu religious life, through which devotees worship their deities, offer prayers and observe traditional rituals. Bhajans are equally important, as they allow Hindus to express their devotion through religious songs and prayers. By stating that he had a serious problem with puja-path and expressing displeasure at the prospect of hearing bhajans from a Hindu temple while travelling to offer namaz, he showed clear resentment towards Hindu devotional practices. His objection was not limited to the volume of loudspeakers; he specifically objected to Hindu worship itself. This made his remarks particularly significant, as they reflected hostility toward Hindu religious practices rather than merely a disagreement over noise. His statements suggested that even the ordinary expression of Hindu faith in the surrounding area was unwelcome to him. For Hindus, performing puja, singing bhajans and offering prayers are natural and deeply personal ways of practising the religion. Treating these practices as objectionable simply because they belonged to Hinduism reflected an intolerant attitude towards Hindu religious identity. His remarks therefore went beyond personal discomfort and demonstrated resentment towards Hindus expressing their faith openly. Such opposition undermined the dignity of Hindu religious practices and conveyed the message that Hindu worship was unwelcome. By expressing hostility towards Hindu temples and treating Hindu religious practices as objectionable, the perpetrator engaged in a form of religiously motivated hostility that fostered division, encouraged intolerance and undermined the right of Hindus to practise their faith with dignity. The explicit threat to burn a temple reflected a deep sense of hostility the Muslim man harboured for Hindus and their faith. Because his remarks were motivated by contempt for the Hindu religion, this incident has been added to the tracker. Disclaimer: The Hinduphobia Tracker records incidents based on when an event occurred or when the victim's ordeal began. None of the media sources covering this case has specified the exact date the incident occurred. Therefore, for documentation purposes, we recorded the date as when the incident was reported in the media: 22 September 2024.

Case Status
Unknown

Perpetrators Details
Perpetrators
Muslim Extremists
Perpetrators Range
One Person
Perpetrators Gender
male
